An argument in favor of the economic advantages of slavery in the south

Or take the case of the many millions in forced labour. And private sector donors want to invest in a way that generates both social and economic good.

Throwing free blacks, whom the Irish generally disliked, into the mix would well-nigh guarantee social chaos. Slavery is acceptable in this culture Slavery was generally accepted by the majority in some societies - if ethics is a matter of public opinion Cultural Ethical Relativism then some would say that slavery was ethically OK in those societies where it was the cultural norm.

The real economic damage is, in practice, much worse than this simple calculation would suggest. If we carefully examine the scriptures we shall find that slavery and oppression were ever abominable in the sight of God Sadly, governments and the private sector are not easily swayed into action for purely humanitarian reasons.

See my book Competition and Coercion: The Greeks had slaves, the Romans had slaves, and the English had slavery until very recently. They collected evidence to show that many resisted or preferred death to transportation.

The enslaved people were unfit for other work. True to his sociological theories, Fitzhugh wanted to extend slavery in the United States to working-class white people, for their own good! Such unrest was used by many as a reason to continue slavery.

Conditions on the slave ships were acceptable. Those enslaved in Africa were usually prisoners of war or victims of political or judicial punishment.

Abraham Lincoln expressed this idea in one of his famous debates with Senator Stephen Douglas: The reality is that while slavery does produce profits for criminal slaveholders and traffickers — it also generates massive costs and losses to the wider economy, over and above the unimaginable human suffering.

People differ, and we must expect that those who are superior in a certain way—for example, in intelligence, morality, knowledge, technological prowess, or capacity for fighting—will make themselves the masters of those who are inferior in this regard.

Ten Reasons Not to Abolish Slavery

No such test is possible, although past cultures thought there could be such tests. Those who defended slavery rose to the challenge set forth by the Abolitionists. For example, Michael Renwick Sergant, a merchant from Liverpool claimed: This argument became popular in the South in the decades before the War Between the States.

In these ways the constitution provided those in favor of slavery with a strong argument. Perhaps, as one variant maintains, every society has slavery because certain kinds of work are so difficult or degrading that no free person will do them, and therefore unless we have slaves to do these jobs, they will not get done.

But if this argument was to be used then there would have to be some certain way of distinguishing natural slaves from those who should not be enslaved - without such a method injustice is sure to occur.

Attempts to justify slavery

Some people take the argument further and say that slaves are beings who are so inferior that they deserve to be enslaved. Here are ten such ideas I have encountered in my reading.

Does the king of Barbess want brandy? Serious people cannot afford to waste their time considering such farfetched ideas. They said that their owners would protect and assist them when they were sick and aged, unlike those who, once fired from their work, were left to fend helplessly for themselves.

Southern Arguments for Slavery

Focussing on the economic benefits of ending this atrocity will help them in enlisting governments and the private sector in this critically important fight. But this is not the case, and the error derives from framing the issue wrongly. Defenders of slavery argued that slavery had existed throughout history and was the natural state of mankind.

And inasmuch as they cannot so live, while they do remain together there must be the position of superior and inferior, and I as much as any other man am in favor of having the superior position assigned to the white race.

This sort of argument is a key reason why many people oppose CER.The Southern Argument for Slavery Those who defended slavery rose to the challenge set forth by Abolitionists.

The defenders of slavery included economics, history, A sudden end to the slave economy would have had a profound and killing economic impact in the South where reliance on slave labor was the foundation of their economy. The. The Pro-Slavery Lobby; Arguments and Justifications; The Act and its effects; nay, even greater advantages than when under their own despotic governments'.

In his publication 'The history of the British West Indies' (published ), This argument was used by Baron Grenville in his speech to the House of Lords when he said, ".

27f. The Southern Argument for Slavery

One argument was that ending slavery would destroy the economy in the south. Another pro-slavery argument was that slavery was a natural state of mankind since it has existed throughout history.

The economic and political advantages of slaves are what ultimately allowed southern citizens to survive. that power belonged to the state, and.

This Essay Southern Arguments for Slavery and other 64,+ term papers, economic, and religious arguments to defend slavery. and the people.

In these ways the constitution provided those in favor of slavery with a strong argument. Economics was an enormous factor in the support of slavery. The South was dependent of slave labor to run 4/4(1). Jan 31,  · This argument has often developed into racism to justify the enslavement of certain population groups - some of the defenders of the Atlantic slave.

In these ways the constitution provided those in favor of slavery with a strong argument. Economics was an enormous factor in the support of slavery.

The economic case for ending slavery

The South was dependent of slave labor to run the large plantations that shipped King Cotton, their main product, out to the North as well as abroad.

Download
An argument in favor of the economic advantages of slavery in the south
Rated 4/5 based on 15 review